Online Payment Services
Indicative Return:
Investment Timeframe
Market Size
Ticket Size
Online/E-commerce payment schemes for SMEs and individual sellers. An e-payment system is a way to make transactions online without the use of physical checks or cash. (5) Online payment structures integrated within e-commerce value chains as well as digital money/wallet solutions that transform mobile phones into pos devices.
Investments in online payment services will increase the revenues of SMEs by facilitating their access to the e-commerce markets.
RegionsDevelopment need: Turkey has a lower penetration of digital services compared to the European average. Among similarly developed economies, Turkey has a lower density of bank accounts, especially among women. The country needs to overcome the challenge of making cashless transactions more attractive and also reach out to those currently underserved. (1
Policy priority: Turkey has an objective to develop a strong institutionsl financial sector to satisfy the needs of real sector and offer alternative financial investors, covering a wide spectrum of investor profiles, while positioning Istanbul as a global financial hub. (2)
Gender inequalities and marginalization issues: Despite major improvements in financial inclusion in Turkey, the gender gap in account ownership is still wide as 30 percentage points. There is also a considerable gap between richer and poorer adults as wide as 20 percentage points, which is comparatively higher than countries with high account ownership. (3)
Investment opportunities: Due to the digital transformation of the economy, digital and remote financial services and products present a great investment opportunity. This is amplified by the effects of COVID-19. The financial sector in Turkey is rapidly growing, with a CAGR of 18% in 2018. (5)
Key bottlenecks: While investing in digital banking tools and services, disparities in household internet access throughout the country should be taken into account.
Development need: There is a need to enhance financial capacity for Turkey to achieve SDGs with a focus on diversification of financial instruments with the contribution of private sector. (4)
Policy priority: Turkey has the ambition to become a cashless society by 2023. (1) Turkey also has a policy priority to form a safe financial technology (fintech) environment to provide equal opportunities for companies based on international good practices. There is also an objective to strengthen alternative financing mechanisms such as impact investments, venture capital, and mass funding. (2)
Gender inequalities and marginalization issues: Turkey has a lower density of bank accounts, especially among women. The country needs to overcome the challenge of making cashless transactions more attractive and also reach out to those currently underserved. (1)
Key bottlenecks: While investing in digital banking tools and services, disparities in household internet access throughout the country should be taken into account.
Critical IOA Unit
Market sizing information for e-commerce transaction is retrieved from the Interbank Card Center.
The expected growth rate for the e-commerce market is retrieved from JP Morgan’s Global Payment Trends Report.
Investors already active in this area estimate annual returns for innovative solutions in e-payment and digital money to be between 25-30% with a minimum range of 10-15% annual returns. Investors can expect 3-5 times return on their investments.
Successful models can generate up to 50-60% IRR as has been observed by recent exits/sales in the industry. (9)
The average exit timespan for these models in Turkey is around 5 years according to interviews with companies already active in this sector.
Turkey has a lower penetration of digital services compared to the European average. (10)
In 2019, 9.15% of SMEs in Turkey sold products online, against an EU average of 16.57 %. It is essential for SMEs to adopt new e-commerce strategies. (11)
Among similarly developed economies, Turkey has a lower density of bank accounts, especially among women. The country needs to overcome the challenge of making cashless transactions more attractive and also reach out to those currently underserved. (10)
In Turkey, there are 15,159 businesses registered where at least one partner is Syrian. (12)
UNHCR estimate for the current number of refugee-owned businesses in Turkey is 8,000. (13)
In a joint study conducted by EBRD and TEPAV in 2018, the major constraint facing Syrian companies in Turkey is access to finance (41.5% of respondents). (14)
This IOA can increase revenues for SMEs by facilitating their access to the e-commerce market through online payment schemes.
This IOA can increase e-commerce volume in Turkey and improve competitiveness. If the increasing trend in export enabled by İyzico is sustained for another three years, US$1 billion of e-commerce volume will be generated only via İyzico. (15)
Advances in this IOA can improve financial inclusion aspects for women who remain relateively unbanked in Turkey, financially empowering them.
Investments in this IOA can help refugee businesses access the formal economy by using online payment schemes.
1.1.1 Proportion of the population living below the international poverty line by sex, age, employment status and geographic location (urban/rural)
1.2.1 Proportion of population living below the national poverty line, by sex and age
1.2.2 Proportion of men, women and children of all ages living in poverty in all its dimensions according to national definitions
Current Level1.1.1: 0.2% (16) 1.2.1: 14.4% 1.2.2:N.A.
Target Level1.1.1: 0% (16) 1.2.1: 0% (16) 1.2.2:0% (16)
8.10.2 Proportion of adults (15 years and older) with an account at a bank or other financial institution or with a mobile-money-service provider
Current Level8.10.2: 68.59% (16)
Target Level8.10.2: 100% (16)
10.1.1 Growth rates of household expenditure or income per capita among the bottom 40 per cent of the population and the total population
Current Level10.1.1: 2% (17) 10.5.1: 3.69% Non-performing loans to total gross loans (17) 1.78% return on assets (17) 10.79% regulatory capital to assets (17) 5.93% NPL net of provisions to capital (17) 64% liquid assets to ST liabilities (17) 1.52% net open position in foreign exchange to capital (17)
Target LevelN.A.
Online payment schemes may increase mass consumption by making the shopping experience easy.
External risk given the interwoven structure of the overall financial system with national and international factors
Stakeholder participation risk given the high lobbying power of the banking sector
Impact Classification
B—Benefit Stakeholders
Important, positive outcome: increased SME and entrepreneur competitiveness and economic growth.
Online payment schemes benefit stakeholders working in SMEs, individual entrepreneurs and other supply chain actors operating in e-commerce sectors.
Cybersecurity, data and technology related risks are prevalent for this business model.
(11th Development Plan): 520. Studies to ensure confidence in e-Commerce will be completed, the market shares will be increased, especially in regions that Turkey has a competitive advantage thanks to geographic and cultural proximity. (18)
(11th Development Plan): 520.2. The software operations of the E-Commerce Information System will be completed and the system will be put into practice in order to make the e-commerce enterprises accessible and to follow the e-commerce data in a healthy way.(18)
(11th Development Plan): 520.3. In regions where Turkey has competitive advantage, e-commerce market share will be increased through bilateral and multilateral agreements.(18)
(Policy document): 11th Development Plan, 249. In order to develop alternative money and payment systems that will be accepted in the international trade system, country collaborations will be established and for this purpose studies will be continued. (18)
(Policy document): 11th Development Plan, Turkey has an ambition to become a cashless society by 2023. (18)
Financial incentives: Fintech startups are eligible for support by TÜBİTAK under the “1512 Techno-Entrepreneurship Support Program (BiGG)”. This is a call-based program that provides up to 200 thousand TRY in seed capital and up to 600 thousand TRY grant for R&D support. (23)
Other incentives: The Ministry of Industry and Technology and The Development and Investment Bank of Turkey established “The Technology and Innovation Fund” under the Turkey Development Fund to finance innovative tech. based companies/projects with a budget of 350 million TRY.
PRIVATE SECTOR
İyzico, BKM Ekspress, İninal, Paynet, Payu Banks, Papara, Param, Birleşik Ödeme, Ödeal, Paraşüt, Boğaziçi Ventures, MV Holding, Revo Capital, 212, Banks
GOVERNMENT
Central Bank of Turkey, BRSA, Ministry of Treasury and Finance, BKM (Bankalararası Kart Merkezi-Interbank Card Center)
MULTILATERALS
IFC/World Bank, EBRD.
NON-PROFIT
SECTOR SOURCES
IOA SOURCES
5) What is an E-Payment System?
7) The Interbank Card Center (BKM), 2020. İNTERNETTEN YAPILAN KARTLI ÖDEME İŞLEMLERİ.
8) J.P. Morgan, 2019. 2019 Global Payments Trends Report – Turkey Country Insights.
9) EF Vostok Emerging Finance. İyzico Exit.
10) BKM, 2017. Cashless Turkey by 2023.
11) EC, 2019. 2019 SBA Fact Sheet Turkey.
12) Statement by the Minister of Trade Turkey, 2019.
14) TEPAV and EBRD, 2018. Syrian Entrepreneurship and Refugee Start-ups in Turkey.
15) İyzico and PAL Consultancy, 2019. Impact of Financial Technologies on the Turkish Economy.
16) Bertelsmann Stiftung & SDSN, 2020. Sustainable Development Report Dashboards 2020. Turkey.
18) Turkey’s 11th Development Plan.
19) Official Gazette, 2013. LAW ON PAYMENT AND SECURITIES SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS, PAYMENT SERVICES AND ELECTRONIC MONEY INSTITUTIONS.
20) Çukur and Yılmaz Law Firm.
21) KPMG, 2020.
22) BRSA, 2020. FAQ.